• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

RealClimate

Climate science from climate scientists...

  • Start here
  • Model-Observation Comparisons
  • Miscellaneous Climate Graphics
  • Surface temperature graphics
You are here: Home / Archives for group

group

Unforced Variations vs Forced Responses?

6 Jun 2019 by group

Guest commentary by Karsten Haustein, U. Oxford, and Peter Jacobs (George Mason University).

One of the perennial issues in climate research is how big a role internal climate variability plays on decadal to longer timescales. A large role would increase the uncertainty on the attribution of recent trends to human causes, while a small role would tighten that attribution. There have been a number of attempts to quantify this over the years, and we have just published a new study (Haustein et al, 2019) in the Journal of Climate addressing this question.

Using a simplified climate model, we find that we can reproduce temperature observations since 1850 and proxy-data since 1500 with high accuracy. Our results suggest that multidecadal ocean oscillations are only a minor contributing factor in the global mean surface temperature evolution (GMST) over that time. The basic results were covered in excellent articles in CarbonBrief and Science Magazine, but this post will try and go a little deeper into what we found.

[Read more…] about Unforced Variations vs Forced Responses?

References

  1. K. Haustein, F.E.L. Otto, V. Venema, P. Jacobs, K. Cowtan, Z. Hausfather, R.G. Way, B. White, A. Subramanian, and A.P. Schurer, "A Limited Role for Unforced Internal Variability in Twentieth-Century Warming", Journal of Climate, vol. 32, pp. 4893-4917, 2019. http://dx.doi.org/10.1175/JCLI-D-18-0555.1

Filed Under: Aerosols, Climate modelling, Climate Science, Greenhouse gases, Instrumental Record

Unforced Variations: June 2019

3 Jun 2019 by group

This month’s open thread for climate science discussions. Remember discussion about climate solutions can be found here.

Filed Under: Climate Science, Open thread

Forced responses: May 2019

2 May 2019 by group

A bimonthly open thread on climate solutions and policies. If you want to discuss climate science, please use the Unforced Variations thread instead.

Filed Under: Open thread, Solutions

Unforced variations: May 2019

2 May 2019 by group

This month’s open thread about climate science topics. For discussions about solutions and policy, please use the Forced Responses open thread.

Filed Under: Climate Science, Open thread

Unforced variations: April 2019

2 Apr 2019 by group

This month’s open thread on climate science issues. Remember that discussions about climate solutions go here.

Filed Under: Climate Science, Open thread

Alpine glaciers: Another decade of loss

25 Mar 2019 by group

Guest Commentary by Mauri Pelto (Nichols College)

Preliminary data reported from the reference glaciers of the World Glacier Monitoring Service (WGMS) in 2018 from Argentina, Austria, China, France, Italy, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Nepal, Norway, Russia, Sweden, Switzerland and United States indicate that 2018 will be the 30th consecutive year of significant negative annual balance (> -200mm); with a mean balance of -1247 mm for the 25 reporting reference glaciers, with only one glacier reporting a positive mass balance (WGMS, 2018).

A view of how alpine glaciers in the Pacific Northwest fit into the broader ecosystem (Megan Pelto, Jill Pelto).
[Read more…] about Alpine glaciers: Another decade of loss

References

Filed Under: Climate Science, hydrological cycle, Instrumental Record

The Crank Shaft

11 Mar 2019 by group

This is a thread for collecting the oddball theories, tinfoil hat-level conspiracies and other climate-related nonsense in the comments that would otherwise derail substantive discussion. Keeping them all in one spot might be of interest to future researchers.

Filed Under: The Crank Shaft

Unforced variations: Mar 2019

3 Mar 2019 by group

This month’s open thread on climate science topics.

Filed Under: Climate Science, Open thread

Forced Responses: Feb 2019

1 Feb 2019 by group

A bimonthly thread on societal responses to climate change. Note that there is another open thread for climate science topics. Please stick to specifics as opposed to arguments about ethics, politics or morality in general.

Filed Under: Climate Science, Open thread, Solutions

Unforced variations: Feb 2019

1 Feb 2019 by group

This month’s open thread for climate science discussions.

Filed Under: Climate Science, Open thread

  • « Go to Previous Page
  • Page 1
  • Interim pages omitted …
  • Page 11
  • Page 12
  • Page 13
  • Page 14
  • Page 15
  • Interim pages omitted …
  • Page 55
  • Go to Next Page »

Primary Sidebar

Search

Search for:

Email Notification

get new posts sent to you automatically (free)
Loading

Recent Posts

  • EPA’s final* ruling on CO2
  • The Climate Science reference they don’t want Judges to read
  • Koonin’s Continuing Calumnies
  • Unforced variations: Feb 2026
  • 2025 Updates
  • A peek behind the curtain…

Our Books

Book covers
This list of books since 2005 (in reverse chronological order) that we have been involved in, accompanied by the publisher’s official description, and some comments of independent reviewers of the work.
All Books >>

Recent Comments

  • Secular Animist on EPA’s final* ruling on CO2
  • Secular Animist on EPA’s final* ruling on CO2
  • Secular Animist on EPA’s final* ruling on CO2
  • Ray Ladbury on EPA’s final* ruling on CO2
  • Tomáš Kalisz on Unforced variations: Feb 2026
  • Ron R. on The Climate Science reference they don’t want Judges to read
  • KirkS on EPA’s final* ruling on CO2
  • Dean Myerson on Unforced variations: Feb 2026
  • Nigelj on Unforced variations: Feb 2026
  • Tomáš Kalisz on 2025 Updates
  • b fagan on EPA’s final* ruling on CO2
  • Radge Havers on The Climate Science reference they don’t want Judges to read
  • Joseph O'Sullivan on EPA’s final* ruling on CO2
  • Radge Havers on The Climate Science reference they don’t want Judges to read
  • Joseph O'Sullivan on A peek behind the curtain…
  • Tomáš Kalisz on 2025 Updates
  • Tomáš Kalisz on EPA’s final* ruling on CO2
  • Michael Brown on EPA’s final* ruling on CO2
  • Ron R. on The Climate Science reference they don’t want Judges to read
  • Paul Pukite (@whut) on Unforced variations: Feb 2026
  • Ken Towe on EPA’s final* ruling on CO2
  • Helmut Syrowatka on EPA’s final* ruling on CO2
  • Barton Paul Levenson on The Climate Science reference they don’t want Judges to read
  • Barton Paul Levenson on The Climate Science reference they don’t want Judges to read
  • Barton Paul Levenson on The Climate Science reference they don’t want Judges to read
  • Barton Paul Levenson on EPA’s final* ruling on CO2
  • Dan on EPA’s final* ruling on CO2
  • Jean-Pierre Demol on EPA’s final* ruling on CO2
  • Spencer Weart on EPA’s final* ruling on CO2
  • Data on EPA’s final* ruling on CO2

Footer

ABOUT

  • About
  • Translations
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Page
  • Login

DATA AND GRAPHICS

  • Data Sources
  • Model-Observation Comparisons
  • Surface temperature graphics
  • Miscellaneous Climate Graphics

INDEX

  • Acronym index
  • Index
  • Archives
  • Contributors

Realclimate Stats

1,398 posts

15 pages

250,251 comments

Copyright © 2026 · RealClimate is a commentary site on climate science by working climate scientists for the interested public and journalists.