• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

RealClimate

Climate science from climate scientists...

  • Home
  • Start here
  • Contributors
  • Archives
You are here: Home / Archives for CMIP6

CMIP6

Issues and Errors in a new Scafetta paper

30 Mar 2022 by Gavin 38 Comments

Earlier this week, a new paper appeared in GRL by Nicola Scafetta (Scafetta, 2022) which purported to conclude that the CMIP6 models with medium or high climate sensitivity (higher than 3ºC) were not consistent with recent historical temperature changes. Since there have been a number of papers already on this topic, notably Tokarska et al (2020), which did not come to such a conclusion, it is worthwhile to investigate where Scafetta’s result comes from. Unfortunately, it appears to emerge from a mis-appreciation of what is in the CMIP6 archive, an inappropriate statistical test, and a total neglect of observational uncertainty and internal variability.

[Read more…] about Issues and Errors in a new Scafetta paper

References

  1. N. Scafetta, "Advanced Testing of Low, Medium, and High ECS CMIP6 GCM Simulations Versus ERA5‐T2m", Geophysical Research Letters, vol. 49, 2022. http://dx.doi.org/10.1029/2022GL097716
  2. K.B. Tokarska, M.B. Stolpe, S. Sippel, E.M. Fischer, C.J. Smith, F. Lehner, and R. Knutti, "Past warming trend constrains future warming in CMIP6 models", Science Advances, vol. 6, 2020. http://dx.doi.org/10.1126/sciadv.aaz9549

Filed Under: Climate modelling, Climate Science, Featured Story, Instrumental Record, Scientific practice Tagged With: CMIP6, Scafetta

Primary Sidebar

Email Notification

get new posts sent to you automatically (free)
Loading

Recent Posts

  • Unforced Variations: May 2022
  • River Ice break-up trends 2022
  • Digital Twinge
  • The modern demarcation problem
  • Issues and Errors in a new Scafetta paper
  • The Future of Climate Modeling?

Our Books

Book covers
This list of books since 2005 (in reverse chronological order) that we have been involved in, accompanied by the publisher’s official description, and some comments of independent reviewers of the work.
All Books >>

Recent Comments

  • Piotr on Unforced Variations: May 2022
  • macias shurly on Unforced Variations: May 2022
  • Kevin McKinney on The modern demarcation problem
  • Adam Lea on The modern demarcation problem
  • MA Rodger on Unforced Variations: May 2022
  • Killian on Unforced Variations: May 2022
  • CCHolley on The modern demarcation problem
  • nigelj on Unforced Variations: May 2022
  • Radge Havers on The modern demarcation problem
  • Kevin McKinney on Unforced Variations: May 2022
  • Carbomontanus on The modern demarcation problem
  • Kevin McKinney on The modern demarcation problem

Footer

ABOUT

  • About
  • Translations
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Page
  • Login

DATA

  • Data Sources
  • Climate model projections compared to observations

INDEX

  • Acronym index
  • Index

Realclimate Stats

1,270 posts

8 pages

227,438 comments

Copyright © 2022 · RealClimate is a commentary site on climate science by working climate scientists for the interested public and journalists.